The losing streak has ended, the Panthers are back in the win column. It was a little close for comfort, but Carolina took home the 20-17 victory in New Orleans, the first time the team has won in the Superdome since 2022.
Winning is hard in the NFL. For Carolina, it was extra difficult on Sunday, as the Panthers had to face not one, but two opponents.
Their on-field matchup New Orleans Saints played quite poorly - quarterback Tyler Shough consistently missed throws and coughed up the ball twice. In total, the Saints gained only 222 yards against the Panthers.
Carolina’s second opponent, however, was a bit more effective. The replacement refereeing crew accounted for a Panthers new franchise record of 152 penalty yards on 17 accepted penalties, also a new franchise record.
What Carolina had to endure was truly despicable. Fortunately, the good guys came away with the close victory. However, the penalty and officiating problem is something the Panthers will still have to work out.
The Good
For the first time this season, the Panthers defense was the better unit on the field on Sunday. Todd Wash’s takeover was in full swing against the Saints, with the defensive front creating problems early for Tyler Shough and the run game.
In total, Carolina allowed 49 rushing yards, half (25) of which were from Shough scrambles. New Orleans returned Travis Etienne Jr. in this game as well, but it didn’t matter - the defensive front, led by Jaelan Phillips, Derrick Brown, and Lee Hunter, absolutely annihilated the run.
Jaelan Phillips’ return was a significant boost for the Panthers. Back when Carolina made the switch from Evero to Wash, I was skeptical that they could pull off even fronts effectively without Phillips in the lineup.
With Phillips back, however, deploying and getting pressure with four was easy. Phillips notched his own sack, accounted for almost a dozen pressures, and recovered the Shough fumble.
Carolina’s secondary played phenomenally as well. All-Pro receiver Chris Olave went missing, only accounting for 30 yards on 3 receptions. Rookie receiver Jordyn Tyson had his best day as a pro (11 receptions, 80 yards), but the bulk of his work came as checkdowns.
Getting pressure with four rushers allowed Wash to deploy the back end of the defense effectively, shutting down Shough’s ability to find open receivers.
If the defense played this well without their top three corners, imagine how good it can be down the stretch when Jaycee Horn, Mike Jackson, and Will Lee III all return.
Next, Chuba Hubbard had a career day. Totaling 172 scrimmage yards (92 rush, 80 receiving) and both Carolina touchdowns, Hubbard was truly the engine of the offense. In fact, it was when the team went away from Hubbard that New Orleans was able to slow down the Panthers’ attack.
Since the early bye week, the Panthers have lacked an identity on offense. Not having a true deep threat in the passing game has limited what Bryce Young can do with the ball. Leaning more into the run, headlined by Hubbard, is a good way to get the offense on track until the deep game can open back up.
Sticking with the offense, Monroe Freeling had by far his best performance of his rookie season. Matching up with Chase Young and Carl Granderson, Freeling allowed only one pressure on 34 pass sets. He did not allow a sack either.
Freeling was left on an island on 27/34 reps. This was a true lockdown tackle performance.
Lastly, we can’t have a game review without mentioning the Panthers uniform combination. This was a classic look from the Panthers. The all-white everything down to the socks is maybe the best road game fit you could ask for.
It meshed particularly well with the Saints all black look, although the Saints are somehow the only team to mess up black helmets. Even the Panthers black helmet, which has it’s flaws, is miles ahead of the Saints look.
Still, this was a classic uniform combination, and the Panthers were able to pull off the win with it. Maybe the only thing I’d change is going blue socks instead of white, but otherwise, I can’t complain. 9.5/10.
The Bad
One of the more frustrating things in this game was the lack of a coherent passing attack. Credit the Saints defense for being able to take Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker away, but it’s still disappointing when the ball doesn’t find playmakers down the field.
Bryce Young ended the day with 200 passing yards, but a good deal of that total were yards after the catch. Frankly, Chuba Hubbard helped pad that stat total quite a lot.
I wouldn’t put it all on Young, I think he was fine considering the pressure he faced and the coverage New Orleans deployed. However, in a game with Xavier Legette active, you would like to see him out there at least as a decoy, stretching the field to help open up the intermediate pass game.
This ties into the next bad part of the game, Brad Idzik’s play sequencing. Too often did Carolina find great success with Chuba Hubbard on the ground, only to completely abandon the run on the next drive.
Sure, penalties helped to mire the Panthers offense, but taking the ball out of Hubbard’s hands when the Saints couldn’t do anything to stop him was an odd choice.
Perhaps from a preservation standpoint, it made sense to limit Hubbard, who ended the day with 32 total touches. Still, this game didn’t have to be as close as it was.
Lastly, Ryan Fitzgerald was able to come through with two huge 50+ yard field goals, including the 55-yard game-winner as time expired. He also missed the first field goal attempt of the game.
It’s good to see him win in the clutch, and perhaps that will break him out of the slump he’s had over the first half of the season, but the missed kicks will catch up to this team eventually.
The Ugly Officiating
This entire section will be dedicated to the horrendous performance put on by the officiating crew on Sunday. Under their purview, Carolina racked up franchise records of 152 yards and 17 accepted penalties.
To be fair to the officials, the Panthers did commit a great many of these penalties. The team has a real discipline problem, which has plagued them throughout the season. There is no excuse for the amount of pre-snap and procedural penalties that Carolina continues to accrue.
That’s not what the fuss is about. There were SEVEN calls that probably wouldn’t have been called by a regular, non-replacement officiating crew.
A Panthers account on Twitter, For Panthers Fans Only, took the liberty of splicing all seven of the calls together, shown below.
These “penalties” occurred as follows:
1Q 3:41 - Offensive Pass Interference against Darren Waller, removing a first down completion, knocking Carolina out of field goal range
2Q 8:16 - Offensive Holding against Luke Fortner, nullifying a Chuba Hubbard touchdown
3Q 15:00 - Unnecessary Roughness against Trevis Gipson, moving Carolina back to the 17 yard line to begin the half
3Q 8:46 - Unnecessary Roughness against Devin Lloyd, pushing New Orleans into the red zone
3Q 1:31 - Unnecessary Roughness against Felipe Franks, negating a Saints net punt of 20 yards
4Q 6:18 - Horse Collar Tackle against Jaelan Phillips, pushing New Orleans deep into Carolina territory
4Q 1:10 - Face Mask against Tyrell Dodson, pushing New Orleans into Carolina territory on their two-minute, game-tying field goal drive
If you watch the clips above, maybe one of these penalties is marginal, at best. These penalties resulted in 95 yards against the Panthers, almost the length of the entire field!
This raw yardage doesn’t take into account the context of the plays in which the “penalties” occurred, such as sacking Tyler Shough for a near-20 yard loss. Or negating a 3rd down completion in Saints territory early in the game. Or negating a 20-yard punt near the end of the third quarter.
In fact, these calls were so influential to New Orleans, that ALL SEVENTEEN POINTS that the Saints scored happened on the drives in which these penalties were called against Carolina.
The New Orleans Saints could not score a single point without the intervention of the officiating crew.
When you remove these bad calls, the game starts to look a bit different. New Orleans is closer to scoring zero points than their box score 17 points. Carolina is also able to convert a few more 3rd downs and get into Saints territory more often.
I won’t go as far as to suggest that this officiating crew tried to rig the game in an effort to help the Saints. But, when you consider that this was a replacement crew due to the FAA issue last Friday, somewhat comprised of referees local to the New Orleans area, it gets a bit murky.
A replay official also was not assigned to this game, all replay reviews took place in New York. Perhaps this allowed the officiating crew to get away with calling these “iffy” penalties.
Still, despite their interference, Carolina was able to pull off the narrow victory.
Officiating crews favoring Carolina’s opponents has been a bit of a theme over the last few weeks. From Matthew Golden getting away with punching a player, to Sean Payton’s challenge flag being accepted postmortem, the Panthers have been up against it.
This can’t be an excuse though. With the win against the Saints, the Panthers are back in the driver’s seat of the division.
Next, Carolina will be back in Charlotte to host the Baltimore Ravens, who just gave the Los Angeles Chargers their first win of the season on Monday Night Football.







